Menu O'Donoghue's Irish Pub

O'Donoghue's Irish Pub in Elm Grove, WI, offers a warm, inviting atmosphere paired with an impressive menu of classic Irish and pub favorites. Patrons rave about standout dishes like the best wings in Wisconsin, authentic Polish sausage with slaw, and the hearty Shepherd's Pie, crafted to satisfy traditional cravings. The menu also features a delightful cod fish fry, an Irish Reuben served with sweet potato fries, and a tempting chicken pot pie that customers call possibly the best they've ever had.

Appetizers such as homemade pub chips with dip are highly addictive, while wraps like the avocado fried chicken wrap offer generous portions ideal for leftovers. The friendly, attentive service, often led by owner Jamie and his team, enhances the dining experience, even on busy nights with live music. Despite occasional slow service and a ventilation system needing upgrades, the pub’s cozy vibe and excellent food make it a beloved local gem for casual bites and lively gatherings alike.